Can you honestly say your team is as good as you would like it to be? Are you confident that they are strong enough to support your growth plans and truly help the company achieve its objectives? Can they take you and your company to the next level? As Jim Collins asks in his book Good to Great, do you have the right people “on the bus?” If you can’t answer yes to these questions, you should be asking yourself why not. Why shouldn’t you be able to say you have assembled the greatest team possible and they are driving your company to new heights?
Whenever I talk to company owners and managers who cannot answer yes to these questions and I ask them why not, I typically get a very standard excuse. I’m told, “It’s just tough to find good people,” or “What can I do? They’ve been with the company for so long,” or “I guess we just deal with it.” The rationalization creating these excuses can be very costly. The ultimate cost is that these employees prevent the company from achieving its growth goals, and actually jeopardize its future.
It is a fact, the ultimate long-term success of every company depends on having good people. And, to reach the heights truly great companies reach, you can’t just settle for good people, you need great people. Great companies understand the importance of great people. They believe it is worth the time, the effort, and the cost to find great people.
Are you thinking, “I just could never get the truly great employees to come to my company?” If you are, then you need to change your thinking. There are truly great employees out there and you can get them. It doesn’t matter if your company is small or doesn’t have all of the bells and whistles of some larger companies. What matters is that you have both the right attitude and a strong commitment. You have to adopt an attitude that only the best will do in your company and you will not put up with mediocrity. And you need to commit resources and efforts to back up that attitude. Although in reality it may be impossible to put together a team consisting only of “A” players, this should never stop you from having it as your objective. If you allow yourself to take the easier route and simply hire employees who are “perhaps not the best but should be able to do the job,” then you can expect your company performance to mirror that philosophy.
Companies often become self-fulfilling prophecies. They think they cannot find and attract the best and their prophecy comes true. Instead of aggressively seeking and recruiting those “best” candidates, they assume they can’t attract them, so they don’t even try. Your goal has to be to become a company that is a top choice of the best players. That means you need to have an environment making the best people want to come work at your company. Think positively. Think what would make your company into the place to be for those employees.
I can almost hear the excuses again. Some of you are already thinking to yourself, “Whatever my attitude, those ‘best’ employees are expensive and there is no way we could afford them.” Although it may sound trite, for the sake of your future, can you afford not to hire the best? And, by being a little more creative, you can design compensation plans that not only attract the best but also make them much more affordable. Remember, although you need to be competitive, salary isn’t always the ultimate attraction.
Take mediocrity out of your vocabulary when you are forming your team. Be committed to an attitude of excellence. Be creative. Think of ways to make your company the place where the best want to be and where the best possible team is busy taking your company to the next level.
It was 1967, and it was my first job in engineering for what was, at that time, one of the top companies in the machine tool industry. This manufacturing company was a young engineer’s dream and as an entry-level engineer, my initial assignments had me directly involved with the workers in the factory. It was there that, in addition to having my first real taste of manufacturing, I had my first real lessons in employee incentives and behavior.
The company was very proud of its factory incentive system. Production employees, in addition to their base wage, received a piecework incentive. Standard times for the manufacturing operations required to make every part were established before it went into full production. The incentive system then paid off if the employee beat the standard time to complete the operation. For example, if a machine operator making a part with a 10-per-hour standard made 12 parts that hour, they would receive 120% of their base hourly rate for that hour.
This seemed like win-win. The company got improved production rates and the workers had an opportunity to make more money. However, I learned productivity was not very good, parts were still late, quality issues were abundant, and costs were high. The system was not achieving what it was intended to achieve. Its intentions were good but its design was flawed. It was, in many situations, actually incenting the wrong behavior. One of the more obvious flaws was that operators got paid their incentive based solely on the quantity of parts produced. There wasn’t a good system in place to ensure the quality of the parts. This often resulted in operators being paid incentives for producing bad parts. And it doesn’t end there. Once the bad parts were discovered, they were often sent back to the same machinist who could earn incentive pay to fix his own mistake.
Its all in the design
The key to a successful system is therefore in the design. It must ensure that, unlike the piecework system described here, it doesn’t inadvertently incent the wrong behavior. This is important in large-scale plans or simple performance rewards.
It’s actually very easy to implement a destructive rather than a constructive incentive program. You have a problem and an incentive program seems like a good way to solve it. You want a quick fix so you don’t spend the time you should to really think out the ramifications and the possible behaviors that could be incented by the plan. Following some simple guidelines can help ensure your design creates the results you intended.
Rules of thumb
1. In designing a plan, don’t focus on only one aspect of the process. It will likely create unwanted behavior in another part of the process. An incentive plan rewarding speed of manufacturing or delivery may also create quality issues.
2. Don’t design the plan to be too general. If it doesn’t identify specific objectives, it enables interpretation that could hurt rather than help the company. A plan designed to reward sales increases without specifically stating target products or price points may result in increased sales of lower-margin, less-profitable products, and a reduction rather than an improvement in company performance.
3. Play the devil’s advocate throughout the design process. Involve your managers and the employees involved to gain insight into their reaction and interpretation. You need to feel comfortable the plan will incent the behavior you intend before you implement it.
Incentives do work
I have heard (and I tend to agree with) the argument: “Why do I need to incent them to do a good job? That’s what I pay them for.” But, designed and used properly, incentives can be a powerful management tool. They can help us solve short-term problems, mold behavior, and develop the company culture. That’s both the good news and the bad. They work so well that, unless designed properly, they could incent unintended and potentially destructive behavior.
Well it has been some time in coming but my blog is finally up and running. So welcome to my blog. The delay was due totally to my procrastination. My web design firm GoFactor Design and my PR advisor Ann Videan of Videan Unlimited told me to do this months ago. When they first suggested it I don’t think I even knew what a blog was but I have finally come into this century and I have a blog.
I think what really convinced me to follow their advice was when I realized that I could use this blog to do what I have enjoyed doing for my entire 25 year consulting career – writing and talking about my thoughts and theories about business growth and creating value and wealth in growing businesses. So that is just what I am going to do. I plan to refer back to some of what I have written for my long running magazine column and for my books as well as expound on new ideas and thoughts about creating growth and wealth. I really like to tell true success stories of businesses I have seen and worked with so I will definitely include some of those in this blog. Of course I will not be able to resist telling some horror stories as well.
I hope you enjoy reading my blog and will visit often and please participate in the discussions that I hope will occur. I will be updating it often. Sharing your input and experiences as owners and managers (and employees) of growing businesses will be invaluable to others.
I am a strong proponent of performance-based compensation so I have decided to use this as the topic for my initial blog entry. Performance based compensation can be a powerful tool for creating a performance-based culture. That is a culture where people take responsibility for their actions and are continuously striving to perform to the best of their abilities. However, for a performance-based compensation or incentive system to bring the desired results requires a carefully designed system. The crucial issue in designing any system is to ensure the incentives actually incent the desired behavior. (The contents of this blog article are taken from my book “Expand Your Entrepreneurial Passion Into Growth and Wealth”)